The Birthing Tree–returning to roots

The Birthing Tree

By Amanda Peter

Published 2026

Read Nov 2026

This reader did not read Peter’s first book, The Berry Pickers, so this reader was not clear about the physical location of the Mi’kmaw community in this book.  Some outside investigation gave this reader information about the geographic range of the Mi’kmaw people which includes the eastern coast of Canada and extends into Maine.   This wasn’t a major distraction, but it was a minor one.

The time setting of the book is clear.  The chapters alternate between the 1960’s-1970’s and the mid-late 1990’s.  Each chapter heading specifies the time period.  The story alternates between when our protagonist, Aliet, is a young girl through high school and when she is in her 40’s. 

We learn in the first sentence that Aliet’s mother, Maggie, died as she was giving birth to Aliet while outside during a storm.  We learn that Kiju, Aliet’s maternal grandmother, is a midwife who has, over several decades, helped many women delivery their babies under The Birthing Tree.  Her maternal grandfather built the small house in which his small family—mother, father, and Maggie’s mother lived.  They owned the land, on the outskirts of town, and lived on their crops and money from his carpentry work, until his death, and Kiju’s work as a medicine woman and midwife for members of their Mi’kmaw community.  White men tried to relocate the community away from the area, but Kiju’s family resisted and retained ownership of the property, which was a fairly short walk from the Birthing Tree.

The 1990’s story line starts when Aliet learns that Kiju has died.  She is working as a nurse in a city a couple of hours from her grandmother but has not visited her grandmother very frequently for some unstated reason(s).  She returns home to find the house in disrepair and calling to her to stay.  She eventually decides to leave her city job, repair the house, and start a new life in her home community. 

There are several sets of questions that the early chapters set up, most, but not all of which get answers at least for this reader.  Why didn’t Aliet interact with her grandmother more once she left for college?  Why does she have a scar on her face? Who was her father (she wants to know this too!!) What happens between Aliet and John as they were childhood sweethearts.  What happened during Aliet’s birth that led to her mother’s death.

A large aspect of the novel regards midwifery in general and midwifery as practiced by the Mi’kmaw in particular.  This book suggests Kiju delivered fewer babies in recent years, in part because the Mi’kmaw community was shrinking locally and the number of transient Mi’kmaw apple pickers that visited the area was decreasing as well.  It also indicates that modern medicine pushed for deliveries by doctors vs midwifes and for deliveries certainly in hospitals vs out of doors.  In one scene, Kiju and Ailet are interrupted during a delivery.   The mother is taken to a hospital during labor despite her protests,  and Kiju and Ailet are taken to the police station in handcuffs although not charged with any crime. 

An overarching plot arc regards Ailet’s transformation from someone who abandoned the teachings of her grandmother (although why is not clear) to someone who does want to carry on her work. 

This reader found the book interesting and looks forward to discussing it in an upcoming library discussion group. 

Shanghai Girls–excellent story and way to learn some history

Shanghai Girls

By Lisa See

Published 2009

Read Nov 2026

This reader is becoming a strong fan of Lisa See.  Previous posts discussed The Island of Sea Women  and China Dolls. 

She writes the type of “historical fiction” that I like—the story is set in real place and time with characters and their stories that are all fictional but consistent with the culture and situations of that time and place.

Shanghai Girls covers the time period 1937-1957 and centers on a pair of sisters from a wealthy family.  We meet them when our protagonist, Pearl, is twenty-one.  She and her younger sister, May, live with their parents, of course as they are unmarried, but they wave off their parents’ attempts at corralling their behavior.  They are models for pictures on calendars, painted by artist Z.G., and they spend their evenings in nightclubs drinking and dancing.  Their lives change when their father announces to the family that they are broke because of his gambling debts.  He has an arrangement with a Chinese American businessman to keep living in the house (although they need to take in borders) but the daughters will become wives for his two sons.  Of course, the girls are mortified but they are married off in a small ceremony and spend one night with their husbands before the husbands and their father leave for business in Hong Kong.  The girls decide to ditch their husbands and don’t meet them as planned in Hong Kong to journey to the US.  When Japanese bombs begin falling on Shanghai, the girls and their mother leave to go to the father’s ancestral village, but tragedy befalls them.  The mother and Pearl are raped by Japanese soldiers while May hides.  The mother dies of her injuries.  May gets Pearl away and they make their long way to Los Angles via San Francisco via Hong Kong hoping to find the businessman and their husbands. 

All ships arriving from Asia at that time arrive in the US at the Angel Island detention center off the coast of San Francisco and passengers are processed for entry into the US.  The situation is quite different from the Ellis Island stories we’ve learned.  Chinese immigrants are put through extensive physical testing and if they pass, they can be indoctrinated about their past to determine whether they have legitimate cause to enter the US.  Many are deported back to China.  Our characters must prove they are married to US citizens and can answer detailed questions about their own backgrounds and that of their husbands and their families. 

Through the story of these characters, we learn about Chinese culture and pressures on it through the years of the book.  See reveals the anti-Chinese environment that Chinese immigrants to the US endure despite being encouraged to come as workers to lay tracks for the railroad extension:  the interrogations at Angel Island, the hunt for “paper sons” in the 1950’s to deport immigrants who have previously been allowed in the country, which include Pearl and May’s family.  See is skilled in using her characters and their story to quietly inform the reader about the situation without giving the impression of lecturing.  An interesting aspect comes through—despite Pearl’s rejection of her parent’s culture while a free-wheeling calendar girl, she seemingly naturally clings to Chinese ways while in the US and hopes that her daughter will find a nice Chinese boy.  So See helps us confront the question—why do some immigrant populations remain devoted to their culture and home country while others seem more assimilated.  Of course, one answer to this question has to do with the willingness of the US culture to accept “others” into “their” country, “others” being readily defined by facial features and complexion.  This tension has been a very active one throughout the US history including today.  

See is a gifted story teller and is talented in bringing to light interesting but unknown (at least to this reader) aspects of Asian history.  This reader will continue to read her work and recommend it without reservation. 

The Witch Elm–an amazing book from Tana French

The Witch Elm

By Tana French

Published 2018

Read Nov 2026

This reader is a Tana French fan and this book really seals the deal.  It’s not part of any series and it diverges from both the Dublin Murder squad series and the later Cal Hooper series in that the protagonist and narrator is neither a current nor former cop of any sort.  Toby is a guy who has considered himself lucky—great job, really great girlfriend, great apartment, great car, great friends, loving generous parents—and who runs out of luck when he is savagely beaten nearly to death by two intruders.  His luck does hold out a little longer—he doesn’t die from his injuries, and the doctors are quick to point out that he was very lucky that someone found him when they did or he would be dead.  But he now must figure out how to claw himself back to living while his head injury has left him with fragmented at best memories of what happened to him, an inability to do the work he used to do, and a total lost sense of self.  No longer is he the confident, articulate young guy who can solve his own small problems and can escalate the brand of the small gallery for whom he is the public relations expert.  Rather he is literally often at a loss for words and can’t participate in any meaningful way with the investigation of the burglary and beating.

In the meantime, his bachelor and beloved Uncle Hugo has been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer and needs assistance to stay in his home, known as The Ivy House, while he lives out his remaining time.  At the behest of cousin, Susannah, Toby agrees to continue his own rehabilitation while helping Uncle Hugo.  Uncle Hugo lives in the childhood house in which he, Toby’s father, and other brothers grew up and in which Toby and cousins Susannah and Leon spent their summer vacations.  Toby’s girlfriend, Melissa, moves into the Ivy House with him and the three of them settle into a lovey routine.   Melissa goes into town to her store that sells funky things.  Toby helps Uncle Hugo with his job as a genealogical investigator.   They make dinner together etc as Uncle Hugo declines and Toby seems to improve. 

The three cousins, Toby, Susannah, and Leon, all of the same age, attended the same schools in Dublin and have taken different paths since graduation:  Toby a PR person after graduation from college; Susannah a stay-at-home mother after dropping out of college; Leon, a fully out (now) gay man who now lives in Berlin with his current lover.  The whole family attends a weekly Sunday lunch at the Ivy House.   At one of these lunches, Susannah’s young children find a skull in the hollow of The Witch Elm which leads to an investigation and a second set of detectives with which Toby must contend. 

The usual mystery questions arise.  Who is the victim?  It turns out the body in The Witch Elm belongs to a former schoolmate of Toby and his cousins who was considered a suicide when he went missing about a decade ago.  Was it suicide or a murder?  How did the body get in the tree?  Why would anyone murder him?  Etc.  Of course, Toby is investigated.  And Toby decides to investigate also.

The story is told solely through Toby’s point of view, and all after the savage attack.   He gives us his view of his life before the beating, his understanding of the beating incident as he recalls the various stages of recovery, his view of the time at Uncle Hugo’s before the skull incident and his view of what happens after it is discovered.  Since he readily confides to us and both sets of investigators that he doesn’t remember many parts of his life before the beating and he confides to us that he is taking a lot of anti-anxiety and pain-relieving drugs, we readers reasonably can doubt his reliability.  But he is all we have so we listen to him intently as he and French reel out the story.  And in true French fashion the story reels out slowly and carefully. 

This reader felt much empathy for Toby at times and wished he would make clearer to the second set of investigators that he is still really suffering from the intense beating he received.  And this reader agreed with Toby’s girlfriend, Melissa, that he should stop trying to play investigator himself; he certainly wasn’t the articulate, intelligent, strategic Toby he had been before the beating, and he didn’t really understand his true capabilities.

Further spoilers won’t be revealed here.  Definitely read the book to find out how this story fully plays out.  It’s not what this reader expected but it’s quite believable.  Definitely read this book as well to enjoy French’s capability to use a mystery story to consider the topics including luck, harassment/bullying and the impact those not directly involved in the harassment/bullying have on the victims, family relationships, and more.  French’s books are never simple mysteries, and this one surely demonstrates her ability to engage the reader in so many ways.

This reader experienced this book through the audiobook produced by Penguin Audio and read by Paul Nugent.  Nugent’s reading was truly magnificent.  He really enabled this reader to feel Toby’s frustration with the long lingering impact of his brain injury and feeling trapped in the stories of his beating and the body in the tree. This reader will look for more books read by this reader. 

The Mad Wife—says who?

The Mad Wife

By Meagan Church

Published 2025

Read Sept 2026

Another book from my favorite librarian’s summer reading list and another one worthy of full recommendation by this reader.

When you goggle this book, you’ll find it classified as historical fiction, suspense, psychological fiction, and domestic fiction.   The first classification caught this reader a little off-guard as this reader was born in the 1950’s, the time setting for this novel.  But hopefully the story in this book could not happen in 2026 when this reader encountered this book.

This is definitely a book that describes a type of family situation found in the 1950’s that is often venerated: a nuclear family lives in a well-coiffured suburb, father is the bread winner, mother is the stay-at-home wife and mother whose sole function in life is to make a safe, clean, stress-free environment for the successful husband and two adorable children.  In this case, the wife is trying desperately to live up to the written (yes there is a published guide for wives) and unwritten expectations of wives in this neighborhood.  Cooking, cleaning, shopping will follow a prescribed weekly schedule.  Dinners will be healthy and beautifully presented as will the wife when she meets her husband at the end of this day at the office.  And the real-life challenges of raising a small child and a new baby who needs mother every two hours day, and night, won’t be noticed by the husband or neighbors. 

The other classifications are all relevant.  The protagonist/narrator wonders how she managed to end up in this suburb after growing up on a farm.  She wonders if there is life beyond collecting award stamps from stores to purchase things for her husband, children, and yes maybe herself.  She wonders what the house across the street is like—identical to hers perhaps but maybe she could decorate it herself (vs her mother-in-law who decorated hers).  She is intrigued by the neighbors that move in and especially the mother and daughter and the rules the mother has for the daughter about play dates. 

So this reader became progressively concerned about this character and the title of the book—Mad Wife.  Would she be declared hysterical and what would happen if she was?  Read the book to find out how Megan Church approaches this topic and what happens to her protagonist, with whom this reader developed an attachment.  It’s a fast read but doesn’t necessarily go where you expect which makes it a truly recommendable

Tana French’s Dublin Murder Squad Series–great reading

Broken Harbor

Published 2012

Read Sept 2026

The Secret Place

Published 2014

Did not finish

The Trespasser

Published 2016

Read Oct 2026

By Tana French

This reader can now finish discussing the 6 book Dublin Murder series by Tana French.  She continues her basic approach: the primary detective in each book is a different member of the Dublin Murder Squad although the secondary detective or another character in the story may have been introduced previously.

Tana French truly takes her time reeling out the story and spends much time in the head of the protagonist, the Murder Squad lead, and sometimes what they are dealing with in the non-work part of their life.  For instance, in Broken Harbor, the manic-depressive sister of the detective plays a significant role in the story.  

Broken Harbor also highlights the real-life context French provides.  The crime occurs in a housing development that was promising when the current inhabitants bought and moved in.  But the crash of 2008 brought the end of investment of the development company building it, and the housing development now sits mainly empty, and the inhabitants stuck in properties they won’t likely be able to sell anytime soon.  This reader was quite engaged by Broken Harbor and fully recommends it as in the same category of great writing and story telling as the first three books, previously described. 

Unfortunately, this reader Did Not Finish The Secret Place.  The story alternates between interviews with several girls at an exclusive all-girls school and scenes in the past of these same girls.  This reader read this book via audio-book and was very annoyed by the voices of these girls.  Additionally, this reader rapidly tired of the high-school drama being described.  As there are so many books to read and limited time, this reader chose to stop reading.  A hardcopy version will likely fix the first issue but perhaps not the second.

The Murder Squad lead in The Trespasser is Antoinette Conway, the only female member of the Murder Squad.  Her partner is Stephen Moran.  Both detectives are fairly new members of the squad and generally work the night shift.  Their cases have often been “by the numbers” lovers quarrel cases which perhaps is the situation of a new case they are assigned just as they are about to go off shift.  A senior squad member, Detective Breslin, is assigned to help the two newer detectives with the case.  Antoinette is very unhappy with her job as she hasn’t been accepted by the guys on the squad and has been the subject of mean tricks by them.  She is so disappointed in how the assignment has worked out that she’s considering leaving it for a lucrative job in the private sector.  Her short and sometimes explosive temper doesn’t help the situation.  She is convinced Breslin is out to get her fired so she views his assignment to the case as over-seer as part of a bigger plot to oust her from the force.  Breslin is strongly promoting Conway and Moran arrest the victim’s boyfriend, but Conway and Moran pursue other angles in the case. The conflict between Conway and Breslin could have done in this reader’s interest in the story, but French’s handling of Conway keeps the wheels on the road so to speak.  The final outcome of the story was unexpected but quite believable.  Another well done story. 

Tana French’s Cal Hooper Series–must reads for all current and future Tana French fans

The Searcher

Published 2020

Read Aug 2026

The Hunter

Published 2024

Read Oct 2026

The Keeper

Published 2026

Read Aug 2026

By Tana French

This trilogy by Tana French is truly exquisite.  There is a mystery embedded in each; part of the mystery is sometimes the question—was there a crime?  But the mystery is only a small treat and piece of these books.  French uses a North Carolina born, retired Chicago cop name Cal Hooper to explore the geography—physical, cultural, political, and economical—of a small town, Ardnatkelty, in mountainous western Ireland.

Cal Hooper moved to very rural Ardnatkelty to live a quiet life in a quiet and beautiful part of Ireland.  He bought a run-down house on a piece of land set between two sheep farmers and went to work to fix it up and figure out how to share the property with a flock of rooks.  His closest neighborhood, Mart Lavin, keeps an eye on the physical progress of improving his house and on his interesting path of becoming part of the community.  Mart provides guidance of a sort which often seems spoken in a kind of riddle to be solved. 

In the first book a young teenager lurks around Cal’s property until Cal finally confronts the person and slowly draws out the reason for the intrusion.  Trey’s older brother is missing and help from the former cop (of course the local gossip chain has already spread this information) is requested to help find out what happened.

This book also introduces Lena, a widow whose sister runs the local general store and thinks Cal would be a good match for her.  Neither party is initially particularly interested in pursuing such a relationship.

In the second book, which this reader read third due to availability of the audiobook, Trey’s father returns to town after four years absence.  He brings with him an Englishman with a claim of kinship with past members of the community and knowledge that might bring economic gain to at least some folks in the area.

In the third book, a well-liked young woman in the community goes missing. She was about to become engaged to the son of a prominent businessman in the community.   What happened and why? 

As with all Tana French books read by this reader, French takes her time exploring. The reader requires some patience but it’s well worth the time and effort.   Who is Cal Hooper?  Is this small town really a quiet idyllic place to settle?  Should an outsider try to become part of the community—what benefits and hazards are associated with this?  How is information stored in the community and how can one access it?  Who holds power in the community and how is it welded?  Can that power structure be shifted?  If the principal industry (sheep farming) is insufficient to support the community, what else can?  Can the community manage the changes required to remain a viable community? 

Some of the answers are likely somewhat universal to small rural towns.  Some of the answers are specific to this part of rural Ireland and driven by the extremely long history of people in this part of the world (literally > thousands of years) and the various trials and tribulations of people making a life in this mountainous area. 

Through these three books, Cal Hooper establishes relationships with his neighbors, Trey, and Lena, which impact his response to the situations mentioned above to the supposedly quiet rural town. 

The True True Story of Raja the Guillible (and His Mother)–just read it!

The True True Story of Raja the Gullible (and His Mother)

By Rabih Alameddine

Published 2025

Read July 2026

This is another book recommended by this reader’s favorite librarian, so it wasn’t surprising that it was a very good read.  And it turns out that it also won the 2025 National Book Award for fiction. 

This book is nearly indescribable.  Set in Lebanon, the story spans the sixty some years of Raja’s life which coincides with the crises Lebanon bore during this period:  the Six-Day War in 1967; Lebanon’s 15-year civil war that began in 1975; its 2019 banking-liquidity crisis; the 2020 covid pandemic; and a massive explosion in Beirut also in 2020.  Raja’s life is impacted directly by a number of these crises, but the most impactful element in his life is his mother, with whom he lives for most of this period.  Add to that Raja’s recognition that he is gay when a young boy and simultaneous realization that’s not a good thing in his community.  Eventually he is known and accepted for being the gay history teacher.

The book is both comedic romp and serious.  It just must be read and experienced.  Then the featured photo will make sense.