Women Talking–complex discussion

Women Talking

By Miriam Toews

Published 2018

Read June 2023

The length of time between reading this novel and writing this post is only due to this reader’s tendency to fall behind in posting and this particular novel getting lost on the list of books.   Rather, this reader strongly recommends this book as well worth reading.  It is extremely well suited for discussion with other readers.

The author indicates her novel is a “reaction through fiction” of real events that occurred during the period 2005-2009 in a remote rural Bolivian Mennonite colony.  During this period, girls and women were sprayed with an animal anesthetic, rendered unconscious, and raped or sexually assaulted.  The attacks were written off by church elders as dreams or fantasies, but pregnancies suggested otherwise.

The book covers a few days when the men folk are in town bailing out the attackers.  Eight women meet in a barn and discuss what they should do.  A young man, recently returned to the community as a teacher after he and his parents were excommunicated, also attends at the request of the women to record their meetings.  (The women are illiterate). 

Questions they consider include:  Should they forgive the men? Will they be able to keep their faith or even enter heaven if they don’t forgive?  Should they stay in the community?  Should they fight the men if they stay?  Where would they go if they left the community and how would they survive?  If they leave the community, should they leave their sons behind or take them and is there an age cutoff for taking them?  Clearly these are life altering questions following clearly life altering events and none of them can be answered with clear black or white criteria. This means the conversations are sometimes disorganized and frustrating for participants.

This book is well constructed, well written and provide much fertile ground for book discussion groups as this reader personally experienced.

Leave a Reply