Whistler–great story from Patchett

Whistler

By Ann Patchett

Published 2026

Read Nov 2026

This is another interesting story from Ann Patchett.  This reader is always impressed with the range of stories she tells us.  No cookie-cutter author is she. 

At the beginning of the book, Daphne and Jonathan Fuller run into Eddie Triplett in the Metropolitan Museum of Art one morning.  Daphne and Eddie hadn’t seen each other for 44 years since Daphne’s mother Abigail, divorced her second husband and Daphne’s first stepfather, Eddie Triplett.  Daphne had been 9 years old at the time.  She blamed herself for the divorce since Eddie had been asked to leave the household (after only about 15 months of marriage) immediately after Eddie and Daphne had survived a car accident in which Eddie had driven the car off the road on a curve and landed the car midway down a steep embankment.  Daphne suffered a cut requiring stitches and Eddie had a shattered ankle, but they were otherwise unharmed.  Daphne, Jonathan, and Eddie have lunch together and Jonathan learns quickly that Daphne and Eddie had clearly loved each other when they were stepfather and stepdaughter. 

Over the course of the book, we eventually learn what happened during that accident and that no one else beside Daphne and Eddie knew as they had never been asked by Abigail;   Daphne’s younger sister was recovering from emergency appendix surgery at the time and hadn’t heard the story either.

We learn that Daphne and Leda’s father and Abigail’s first husband, Buddy, had left the family when Daphne was four to pursue his true calling-being a fisherman in Gloucester.  We also learn that Abigail married a third time when Daphne was twelve, to Lucas, who was about twenty years her senior, and had two sons with him.

So we have several current and past marriages and their components whose current and past interactions the book considers :  Abigail and Buddy, Abigail and Eddie, Abigail and Lucas, Daphne and Jonathan (also older than Daphne by about a dozen or so years), sister Leda and Steve, and Eddie’s close friends, Polly and Skip Hotalling.  Abigail and Buddy met in college.  Abigail was a publicist at the publishing firm in which Eddie was an editor.  Abigail was Lucas’s publicist for his hit series about Positivity.  Skip and Polly met at a dance the night Skip and Eddie, who were college roommates, graduated.  When written out this way it sounds like it could be a soap opera.  Except it’s not.  Daphne and Leda are 53 and 51 during this story and everyone else is 10-30 years older.  They are all adults and fortunately they act like mature adults.  Abigail and her daughters had good relationships with Buddy, who died a number of years previously.  Daphne and Leda have no real relationship with their second stepdad but not a negative one; they get along fine with their half-brothers.  Both girls adored Eddie and vice versa although their relationship was short-lived until this reunion with which everyone seems fairly or immensely pleased.  Daphne and Jonathan met while Buddy was sick (Jonathan having been a hospital administrator).  And finally, Daphne and Leda have a very close relationship foraged, at least a bit, by having gone through so many fathers together. 

One could also wonder if the book is saccharine sweet with all these people getting along pretty well.  It could have been, but none of them are sugary sweet people, they all have real lives with real struggles and they’re all getting along the best they can.  But it is so nice to read about people re-finding each other and getting to rekindle positive and strong relationships.  It is so nice to have people dealing with death (Jonathan going through his parents’ home to prepare for sale after the death of his mother) and dying (read the book to learn which characters that applies to) supporting each other.  Real people can actually be kind to each other even when they drive each other crazy in some ways. 

There is much to unpack in an upcoming book discussion this reader will attend.  This reader recommends you read this book too and find someone/some people with whom to discuss it. 

Leave a Reply