Shanghai Girls
By Lisa See
Published 2009
Read Nov 2026
This reader is becoming a strong fan of Lisa See. Previous posts discussed The Island of Sea Women and China Dolls.
She writes the type of “historical fiction” that I like—the story is set in real place and time with characters and their stories that are all fictional but consistent with the culture and situations of that time and place.
Shanghai Girls covers the time period 1937-1957 and centers on a pair of sisters from a wealthy family. We meet them when our protagonist, Pearl, is twenty-one. She and her younger sister, May, live with their parents, of course as they are unmarried, but they wave off their parents’ attempts at corralling their behavior. They are models for pictures on calendars, painted by artist Z.G., and they spend their evenings in nightclubs drinking and dancing. Their lives change when their father announces to the family that they are broke because of his gambling debts. He has an arrangement with a Chinese American businessman to keep living in the house (although they need to take in borders) but the daughters will become wives for his two sons. Of course, the girls are mortified but they are married off in a small ceremony and spend one night with their husbands before the husbands and their father leave for business in Hong Kong. The girls decide to ditch their husbands and don’t meet them as planned in Hong Kong to journey to the US. When Japanese bombs begin falling on Shanghai, the girls and their mother leave to go to the father’s ancestral village, but tragedy befalls them. The mother and Pearl are raped by Japanese soldiers while May hides. The mother dies of her injuries. May gets Pearl away and they make their long way to Los Angles via San Francisco via Hong Kong hoping to find the businessman and their husbands.
All ships arriving from Asia at that time arrive in the US at the Angel Island detention center off the coast of San Francisco and passengers are processed for entry into the US. The situation is quite different from the Ellis Island stories we’ve learned. Chinese immigrants are put through extensive physical testing and if they pass, they can be indoctrinated about their past to determine whether they have legitimate cause to enter the US. Many are deported back to China. Our characters must prove they are married to US citizens and can answer detailed questions about their own backgrounds and that of their husbands and their families.
Through the story of these characters, we learn about Chinese culture and pressures on it through the years of the book. See reveals the anti-Chinese environment that Chinese immigrants to the US endure despite being encouraged to come as workers to lay tracks for the railroad extension: the interrogations at Angel Island, the hunt for “paper sons” in the 1950’s to deport immigrants who have previously been allowed in the country, which include Pearl and May’s family. See is skilled in using her characters and their story to quietly inform the reader about the situation without giving the impression of lecturing. An interesting aspect comes through—despite Pearl’s rejection of her parent’s culture while a free-wheeling calendar girl, she seemingly naturally clings to Chinese ways while in the US and hopes that her daughter will find a nice Chinese boy. So See helps us confront the question—why do some immigrant populations remain devoted to their culture and home country while others seem more assimilated. Of course, one answer to this question has to do with the willingness of the US culture to accept “others” into “their” country, “others” being readily defined by facial features and complexion. This tension has been a very active one throughout the US history including today.
See is a gifted story teller and is talented in bringing to light interesting but unknown (at least to this reader) aspects of Asian history. This reader will continue to read her work and recommend it without reservation.