The Witch Elm–an amazing book from Tana French

The Witch Elm

By Tana French

Published 2018

Read Nov 2026

This reader is a Tana French fan and this book really seals the deal.  It’s not part of any series and it diverges from both the Dublin Murder squad series and the later Cal Hooper series in that the protagonist and narrator is neither a current nor former cop of any sort.  Toby is a guy who has considered himself lucky—great job, really great girlfriend, great apartment, great car, great friends, loving generous parents—and who runs out of luck when he is savagely beaten nearly to death by two intruders.  His luck does hold out a little longer—he doesn’t die from his injuries, and the doctors are quick to point out that he was very lucky that someone found him when they did or he would be dead.  But he now must figure out how to claw himself back to living while his head injury has left him with fragmented at best memories of what happened to him, an inability to do the work he used to do, and a total lost sense of self.  No longer is he the confident, articulate young guy who can solve his own small problems and can escalate the brand of the small gallery for whom he is the public relations expert.  Rather he is literally often at a loss for words and can’t participate in any meaningful way with the investigation of the burglary and beating.

In the meantime, his bachelor and beloved Uncle Hugo has been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer and needs assistance to stay in his home, known as The Ivy House, while he lives out his remaining time.  At the behest of cousin, Susannah, Toby agrees to continue his own rehabilitation while helping Uncle Hugo.  Uncle Hugo lives in the childhood house in which he, Toby’s father, and other brothers grew up and in which Toby and cousins Susannah and Leon spent their summer vacations.  Toby’s girlfriend, Melissa, moves into the Ivy House with him and the three of them settle into a lovey routine.   Melissa goes into town to her store that sells funky things.  Toby helps Uncle Hugo with his job as a genealogical investigator.   They make dinner together etc as Uncle Hugo declines and Toby seems to improve. 

The three cousins, Toby, Susannah, and Leon, all of the same age, attended the same schools in Dublin and have taken different paths since graduation:  Toby a PR person after graduation from college; Susannah a stay-at-home mother after dropping out of college; Leon, a fully out (now) gay man who now lives in Berlin with his current lover.  The whole family attends a weekly Sunday lunch at the Ivy House.   At one of these lunches, Susannah’s young children find a skull in the hollow of The Witch Elm which leads to an investigation and a second set of detectives with which Toby must contend. 

The usual mystery questions arise.  Who is the victim?  It turns out the body in The Witch Elm belongs to a former schoolmate of Toby and his cousins who was considered a suicide when he went missing about a decade ago.  Was it suicide or a murder?  How did the body get in the tree?  Why would anyone murder him?  Etc.  Of course, Toby is investigated.  And Toby decides to investigate also.

The story is told solely through Toby’s point of view, and all after the savage attack.   He gives us his view of his life before the beating, his understanding of the beating incident as he recalls the various stages of recovery, his view of the time at Uncle Hugo’s before the skull incident and his view of what happens after it is discovered.  Since he readily confides to us and both sets of investigators that he doesn’t remember many parts of his life before the beating and he confides to us that he is taking a lot of anti-anxiety and pain-relieving drugs, we readers reasonably can doubt his reliability.  But he is all we have so we listen to him intently as he and French reel out the story.  And in true French fashion the story reels out slowly and carefully. 

This reader felt much empathy for Toby at times and wished he would make clearer to the second set of investigators that he is still really suffering from the intense beating he received.  And this reader agreed with Toby’s girlfriend, Melissa, that he should stop trying to play investigator himself; he certainly wasn’t the articulate, intelligent, strategic Toby he had been before the beating, and he didn’t really understand his true capabilities.

Further spoilers won’t be revealed here.  Definitely read the book to find out how this story fully plays out.  It’s not what this reader expected but it’s quite believable.  Definitely read this book as well to enjoy French’s capability to use a mystery story to consider the topics including luck, harassment/bullying and the impact those not directly involved in the harassment/bullying have on the victims, family relationships, and more.  French’s books are never simple mysteries, and this one surely demonstrates her ability to engage the reader in so many ways.

This reader experienced this book through the audiobook produced by Penguin Audio and read by Paul Nugent.  Nugent’s reading was truly magnificent.  He really enabled this reader to feel Toby’s frustration with the long lingering impact of his brain injury and feeling trapped in the stories of his beating and the body in the tree. This reader will look for more books read by this reader. 

Leave a Reply