Nemesis–a Roth masterpiece

Nemesis

By Philip Roth

Published 2010

Read Feb 2026

This was Philip Roth’s last novel and is a relatively short one, specifically because he felt the reading public was shrinking and becoming impatient readers.  Fortunately, he packs a wallop in this physically small 279-page book. 

The setting is 1944 in the Jewish Weequahic section of Newark, a time and place Roth inhabited while 11 years old.   It’s very hot and humid during the summer and there was no air-conditioning to moderate the weather. 

Twenty-three year old Bucky Cantor is the neighborhood playground director that summer as well as the physical education instructor at Chancellor Avenue School.  His goal was to teach phys ed and coach at Weequahic, the high school next to Chancellor.  His high school buddies were serving in the war effort, but Bucky was rejected from the armed services due to poor eyesight.  He is embarrassed and feels guilt about this rejection.

Polio cases had started being reported in the city, none in Weequahic when the story begins, but that changes.  Several boys that participated in Bucky’s neighborhood center baseball games develop polio, and two die.  Unsurprisingly parents panic and want action. 

The cause of polio and its transmission routes were unknown in 1944.  It was a disease that regularly cropped up in the summer.  But how did it spread and who was susceptible?   Who would end up in iron lung machines, the ventilators of the time?  Who would die?  How could you protect yourself and your family from this vicious disease?  None of these questions had answers at the time.  Roth, writing in 2010, knew that carriers of the disease eliminate vast quantities of the virus in their feces.  Oral contact with shed virus is the route of infection.  The virus can survive in water for some time so infection during swimming was a common route.  Roth sets up several possibilities for transmission of the virus at various times in the book but deftly casts doubt on whether specific people were the vectors for transmission.  He creates well the general sense of desperation and panic that not inappropriately accompanies an epidemic whose sources are unknown, an experience present during the pre-vaccine Covid epidemic as well.

Bucky Cantor, who was rejected by the armed services attempts to expand his perceived role as developer of strong bodies and minds of his students and playground participants to include a fighter against the disease.  He scrubs away spit on the street left by teenagers from a nearby Italian neighborhood who joked they were spreading the disease.  He visits families of afflicted boys to offer support and attends their funerals when they succumb.  He limits time on the playing field in the heat of the day.  He takes  personally verbal poundings from distressed parents who worry that not enough is being done by the city to prevent spread of the disease.  In the meantime, his girlfriend begs him to accept a newly opened position at a camp in the mountains where she is serving as a counselor.  The fresh air of the camp and distance from the city seems to make it safe from the disease.    He finally agrees and gives notice of his resignation to his boss who is quite disturbed by his decision.  The city closes all of the playgrounds only days after Bucky leaves his position, but his resignation provides him with another source of remorse for his perceived dereliction of duty.  Ultimately, the camp is not safe from polio and Bucky takes responsibility for bringing the disease to the camp, despite evidence to the contrary. 

Thus, Roth does at least two things with this book.  First, he describes what could have happened in his community had polio struck it in 1944 (it didn’t).  Second, he presents the character of Bucky Cantor and his various reactions to the circumstances of his life.  After rising above his physical limitations of size and eyesight to become a successful javelin thrower, weight lifter, and phys ed teacher, his reactions to the polio crisis lead him on a very different protectory, some of which was clearly his own choosing. 

This reader has not read Roth’s previous works and cannot comment on how this one is similar or different than others, but this reader strongly recommends this book as one that is well worth reading and discussing. 

Leave a Reply