What Massie Knew
By Henry James
Published 1897
Read Oct 2025
Maisie’s parents, Ida and Beale Farange, at one point must have at least tolerated each other since they did marry and produce a daughter. Ida apparently brought some money into the marriage. About the time Beale had run through all of it, they had both run through all their tolerance for each other and so one of them initiated a divorce. The divorce process was bitter with both parents vying for Maisie—but clearly only to spite the other party. The court decrees the parents will trade time with their daughter. We learn these details over the course of watching Maisie watch her parents as they treat her as a ping-pong ball and seek to use her as a missile of hostility and rancor toward the other parent.
Maisie does not participate in her parents’ battles, which earns her the opinion of both parents that she is rather dull. Neither parent pays her any attention while she is in their keep, aside from supplying her a nanny. Maisie’s mother sends Maisie to her father with her nanny, the young and attractive Miss Overmore. This reader supposed this happened so that the mother wouldn’t need to pay Miss Overmore while Maisie was away and to perhaps have a willing missile of rancor that Maisie doesn’t provide. Beale Farange takes a shine to Miss Overmore and keeps her on after Maisie’s term with him. This confuses Maisie who previously loved Miss Overmore, although the nanny was clearly spending less time with Maisie. Maisie gets a new nanny at her mother’s home, Mrs Wix, who is even less of a teacher than Miss Overmore, but the parents have no concern for Maisie’s education or development of any sort. When Maisie returns to her father’s, Miss Overmore is now Mrs Beale, her step-mother, and Mrs Wix continues as her nanny.
Maisie’s mother has a new beau, Sir Claude, who takes a paternal interest in Maisie and brings her gifts including educational materials. Maisie’s mother is interested in Sir Claude’s money and manages to get him to marry her at which point she begins (or continues?) to see other men with money. Beale Farange got Miss Overmore but she didn’t bring money to the marriage so he continues to associate with women who do have money and considers going to America with one of them. He’s quite willing to leave Maisie behind with her mother who has also lost complete interest in Maisie. So Maisie gets into an odd state of having two parents who are trying to rid themselves of her. Her parents’ current spouses and Mrs. Wix are the only people who have any interest in Maisie.
In the meantime, Sir Claude continues to interact paternally with Maisie and comes into the good graces of Mrs. Wix as well. Mrs. Wix begins to dream of Sir Claude buying a small cottage for her and Maisie in which he could also live. He doesn’t dissuade her from this dream, at least initially. However, Sir Claude has met Miss Overmore, begins meeting her on a regular basis, and Mrs. Wix becomes aware of this as does Maisie.
Eventually Sir Claude sends Maisie and Mrs. Wix to France to wait for him to join them. After Sir Claude arrives, there is much tension between each pair of Sir Claude, Maisie, and Mrs. Wix. This section spends time on the discussions between each pair. It seems Mrs. Wix and Maisie have very different understandings of what the relationship between Sir Claude and Miss Overmore/Mrs Beale is. Mrs. Wix is aghast that Maisie sees the four of them—including Miss Overmore—living together as a suitable happy ending. “Does she have any moral sense” she keeps asking Maisie who is clearly confused by this question. Mrs. Wix pushes Sir Claude to do the right thing. Sir Claude has very vague discussions with Maisie which mainly increase her confusion about the whole situation. When Miss Overmore/Mrs Beale arrives, tensions mount further. This reader will leave to you how all of this resolves.
As the time frame from our initiation into Maisie’s situation to the situation in France is not clear, it’s left to the reader to decide how old Maisie throughout the story. This could perhaps influence What Maisie Knew—she’s not old enough to fully understand things, perhaps. But it may not be the only thing that influences What Maisie Knew. We don’t learn of any interactions between Maisie and anyone in the “outside world”, which may not have actually occurred, so that she likely has limited knowledge of things an no outside source of an implanted a “moral sense”. Certainly, Miss Overmore and Mrs Wix haven’t taught her anything in this regard nor have her parents. What happens next is unclear. Such ambiguity is a wonderful element of this novel and one that provides much fertile ground for discussion. Enjoy this well designed and well written novel!
MarshaReads.com 