Tana French’s Dublin Murder Squad Series–great reading

Broken Harbor

Published 2012

Read Sept 2026

The Secret Place

Published 2014

Did not finish

The Trespasser

Published 2016

Read Oct 2026

By Tana French

This reader can now finish discussing the 6 book Dublin Murder series by Tana French.  She continues her basic approach: the primary detective in each book is a different member of the Dublin Murder Squad although the secondary detective or another character in the story may have been introduced previously.

Tana French truly takes her time reeling out the story and spends much time in the head of the protagonist, the Murder Squad lead, and sometimes what they are dealing with in the non-work part of their life.  For instance, in Broken Harbor, the manic-depressive sister of the detective plays a significant role in the story.  

Broken Harbor also highlights the real-life context French provides.  The crime occurs in a housing development that was promising when the current inhabitants bought and moved in.  But the crash of 2008 brought the end of investment of the development company building it, and the housing development now sits mainly empty, and the inhabitants stuck in properties they won’t likely be able to sell anytime soon.  This reader was quite engaged by Broken Harbor and fully recommends it as in the same category of great writing and story telling as the first three books, previously described. 

Unfortunately, this reader Did Not Finish The Secret Place.  The story alternates between interviews with several girls at an exclusive all-girls school and scenes in the past of these same girls.  This reader read this book via audio-book and was very annoyed by the voices of these girls.  Additionally, this reader rapidly tired of the high-school drama being described.  As there are so many books to read and limited time, this reader chose to stop reading.  A hardcopy version will likely fix the first issue but perhaps not the second.

The Murder Squad lead in The Trespasser is Antoinette Conway, the only female member of the Murder Squad.  Her partner is Stephen Moran.  Both detectives are fairly new members of the squad and generally work the night shift.  Their cases have often been “by the numbers” lovers quarrel cases which perhaps is the situation of a new case they are assigned just as they are about to go off shift.  A senior squad member, Detective Breslin, is assigned to help the two newer detectives with the case.  Antoinette is very unhappy with her job as she hasn’t been accepted by the guys on the squad and has been the subject of mean tricks by them.  She is so disappointed in how the assignment has worked out that she’s considering leaving it for a lucrative job in the private sector.  Her short and sometimes explosive temper doesn’t help the situation.  She is convinced Breslin is out to get her fired so she views his assignment to the case as over-seer as part of a bigger plot to oust her from the force.  Breslin is strongly promoting Conway and Moran arrest the victim’s boyfriend, but Conway and Moran pursue other angles in the case. The conflict between Conway and Breslin could have done in this reader’s interest in the story, but French’s handling of Conway keeps the wheels on the road so to speak.  The final outcome of the story was unexpected but quite believable.  Another well done story. 

Leave a Reply